[TACRAO] Listserv discipline issues on transcript?

Wortham, Trudy C. WorthamT at uhv.edu
Mon Nov 10 09:05:29 CST 2014


Jeff,

Despite of what the AACRAO guidelines say, our Title IX folks are requesting to have disciplinary/dismissal information posted on the transcript.  I personally and professionally agree that the transcript should only contain academic information.  However, I have no choice but to post the information if our legal department approves the request.

Trudy


Trudy Wortham, M.Ed.
Registrar
University of Houston-Victoria
3007 N. Ben Wilson
Victoria, TX  77901
(361) 570-4121
Fax: (361) 580-5545







-----Original Message-----
From: tacrao-bounces at tamuc.edu [mailto:tacrao-bounces at tamuc.edu] On Behalf Of Jeff Rhodes
Sent: Monday, November 10, 2014 8:42 AM
To: tacrao at tamuc.edu
Subject: Re: [TACRAO] Listserv discipline issues on transcript?

Susan,

It's technically allowed on the transcript, but AACRAO guidelines recommend against it.  The transcript should contain only academic information.

JHR


Jeff Rhodes, Ed.D.
University Registrar
The University of Texas-Pan American
SSB 1.150
1201 W. University Drive
Edinburg, TX 78539
www.utpa.edu/registrar
www.utpa.edu/registration
956.665.3109

"Never, never, never, never, NEVER give up!"
-Winston Churchill

-----Original Message-----
From: tacrao-bounces at tamuc.edu [mailto:tacrao-bounces at tamuc.edu] On Behalf Of Stoker, Dr. Susan
Sent: Monday, November 10, 2014 8:38 AM
To: tacrao at tamuc.edu
Subject: [TACRAO] Listserv discipline issues on transcript?

I am interested in hearing from everyone, but especially A&M System schools. 

Are you asking any criminal history questions on the application? 
If so, are you basing any kind of admission decisions on this criminal history?
Are you basing any other kind of decision on the criminal history (i.e. sex offender, so they can't live in a dorm) Do you ask transfer students about discipline history at their other school? 
Do you put any kind of discipline history on the transcript? 
If yes, do you decide WHAT kind of discipline history goes on there? (i.e. behavioral vs academic (cheating)) If yes, if the disciplinary action is pending do you put THAT on a transcript? (that it's pending) Do you withhold transcripts if there is disciplinary action on the student? 
Do you tell other schools about the disciplinary action given to a student? 
If another school calls to ask, do you inform the school about disciplinary action?

This conversation has come up here at Tarleton and we are wondering if anyone else in the state of Texas is doing anything like the above. 
It appears to be "legal" as far as FERPA goes...see below. 

I checked the FERPA guide and this is what it says about disciplinary info on a transcript:
FERPA does not address what information a school may or may not maintain or print on a transcript. Thus, the institution can decide whether or not to include behavioral issues on a student's transcript. Any info appearing on a transcript must be protected and/or disclosed in compliance with FERPA.

As far as disclosing disciplinary records, FERPA says this:
The Family Police Compliance Office, in its 1996 regulations, stated that an educational agency or institution "may include information in a student's education records concerning disciplinary action taken against the student for conduct that posted a significant risk to the safety or well-being of that student, other students, or other members of the school community". It went further to say that an institution may disclose, without prior consent, information contained in a student's education records concerning disciplinary action taken against the student, described above, to teachers and school officials who have legitimate educational interests in the behavior of the student. 
This means that institutions may disclose, without the student's prior written consent, information about certain disciplinary actions taken against the student to other institutions regardless of level (K-12 to postsecondary) and that the student does not have to be either (1) in attendance at the other institution or (2) seeking or intending to enroll in another institution.
(p. 26-27 in the AACRAO 2012 Ferpa Guide)


Sorry to start out a Monday with legal mumbo jumbo! :) Any insight would be appreciated. Thanks Susan


Susan Stoker, Ph.D.
Registrar
Box T-0620 | Tarleton State University | Stephenville, TX 76402
Phone (254) 968-9120             Fax     (254) 968-9389
                                          www.tarleton.edu/registrar




_______________________________________________
TACRAO mailing list
TACRAO at tamuc.edu
http://mailman.tamuc.edu/mailman/listinfo/tacrao
_______________________________________________
TACRAO mailing list
TACRAO at tamuc.edu
http://mailman.tamuc.edu/mailman/listinfo/tacrao


More information about the TACRAO mailing list